AdCyte

Use approved facts and source evidence to review a draft

By AdCyte8 min read
Abstract purple illustration of a written page with lines linked to a video frame on one side and a separate reference card on the other.
Video knowledge, beyond the campaign. Editorial illustration for AdCyte.

What you'll achieve

You will review a complete written draft, check its important statements against the right sources and retain a corrected version. You will also record any unresolved detail and make the handover to publication clear.

Use this workflow after creating a description, answer, article or destination-specific post in AdCyte. The source-checking guide covers an individual finding; this guide checks how findings and additional facts have been combined in the finished writing.

Before you start

Have the intended draft, its source video and the relevant approved product information available. Confirm the audience, destination, product variant and market. Keep the applicable brand guidance nearby, along with somewhere to record review decisions using your team's existing process.

Identify the version you are reviewing before editing. If copy has already been published, retain the public destination and current wording so the later update can be checked separately. A corrected draft does not, by itself, change a live page.

1. Read the complete draft against its brief

Open the intended output and read it from the headline through to the final link or CTA. Check whether it answers the chosen question and uses the correct product identity. Include FAQs, image captions and preview text if they are part of the output.

Mark statements that need support: product attributes, sizes, availability, performance, comparisons and claims about customer behaviour. Include implied claims created by words such as “only”, “all”, “best” and “always”. A small word can give a sentence a surprisingly large job.

If a sentence contains several assertions, separate them in your review notes. You can then correct one detail while retaining the useful supported parts.

Check: You have a defined draft and a manageable list of statements to review, with its intended audience and destination understood.

2. Identify the source each statement needs

For each statement, decide whether its support should come from the footage, approved product information or an editorial interpretation. Keep missing evidence visible rather than assigning a source merely because a sentence sounds plausible.

The footage can establish that a product appears in a particular scene or that a demonstration takes place. An approved product source may establish the current range or the applicable specification. An interpretation explains how you read the creative and needs wording that makes that status clear.

Use AdCyte's available source references and supplied context to locate the material. Where you need an external product sheet, consult it through your normal authorised workflow. Record the source in your review notes if there is no suitable product field.

Expected result: Each important statement has an appropriate source to check, or a recorded evidence gap. The review is no longer relying on the draft's confident delivery.

3. Check the evidence and its scope

Replay the relevant video sequence, including audio and on-screen text. Confirm the product identity and any qualification. Then check additional product facts against the current approved source for the intended market and period.

If the sources conflict, establish whether they concern different versions, markets or dates. Ask the responsible owner to resolve a genuine uncertainty. Do not combine incompatible details into a sentence that appears to settle the matter.

For this worked exercise, suppose the video shows a diet cola can being poured over ice at a barbecue. The approved UK product sheet confirms that this variant is available in a 330 ml can and a 500 ml bottle. No customer-preference evidence has been supplied. These are example inputs for the exercise; use your actual verified facts when reviewing real copy.

Consider this draft:

The ad shows diet cola being poured over ice at a barbecue. Available only in a 330 ml can, it is the drink customers prefer for summer gatherings. Find it at your nearest supermarket.

The first sentence describes the footage. The rest introduces a range restriction, a preference claim and a local-availability suggestion that require separate checks.

Check: You have assessed the complete meaning of each statement and confirmed where the supplied evidence stops.

4. Decide what to retain, correct or hold

Record a short decision for each important statement. The table below illustrates a working review record; it is not a set of required AdCyte status controls.

StatementAvailable supportReview decision
The ad shows the drink poured over ice at a barbecueThe relevant video sequenceRetain if the actual scene matches
Available only in a 330 ml canProduct sheet lists a can and a bottleCorrect the range statement and identify the UK scope
Customers prefer it for summer gatheringsNo preference evidence suppliedRemove the claim; retain a description of the ad's setting if useful
Find it at your nearest supermarketNo current local stock information suppliedRemove or replace with a verified product or stock-information link

Treat a missing source as an unresolved question. You may be able to publish the rest of the explanation after removing that detail, provided the remaining copy still serves its purpose. Hold the affected output if the unresolved point is essential to the answer.

Expected result: The review produces specific edits and clear open questions. “Needs work” has been replaced by something another colleague can act on.

5. Edit the draft and retain the intended revision

Apply the corrections to the written output using the current editing workflow. Preserve useful wording and deliberate manual edits. If you choose to generate a fresh version, compare the full result again; a corrected instruction does not guarantee that every sentence in a new draft is correct.

A revised paragraph for the example could read:

The ad shows diet cola being poured over ice at a barbecue. In the UK, the featured variant is available in a 330 ml can and a 500 ml bottle. The scene presents the drink as part of a relaxed outdoor meal, with the product shown during the serving sequence.

This keeps the observed action, corrects the range and describes the scene without claiming to know customer preferences. An appropriate verified link could follow, but it should not imply local stock availability unless that information has been checked.

Save the revision and confirm which version now contains the intended wording. Retain the source references and review notes through the available product functions or your established team process. Do not assume an unsaved editor view is the version somebody else will receive.

Check: You can reopen the corrected output and identify its supporting sources. This example is an editorial illustration, not a recorded AdCyte test result.

6. Recheck the final output and prepare the handover

Read the full revised piece, including headline, summary, FAQs, captions and CTA. Confirm that the changes agree with each other and the original brief. Check product naming, market scope and links alongside tone and formatting.

For any shorter adaptation, repeat the claim check in that version. Removing half a sentence for a social post can also remove the qualification that made the statement accurate. Review the meaning the reader will actually encounter.

Record the intended destination, revision, reviewer, review date and remaining action. If the content has already been published, identify the live update as a separate task. Use the supported publishing route, then check the result at the destination when the update is authorised and completed.

Expected result: You have a reviewed draft and a clear handover. The record distinguishes corrected copy, normal approval and confirmed publication rather than bundling them into one reassuring tick.

Common problems and fixes

ProblemWhat to do next
A source supports only part of a sentenceSplit the claims and correct or remove the unsupported part.
The approved fact and video disagreeCheck version, market and date, then ask the source owner to resolve the conflict.
The rewritten draft loses a useful manual editCompare revisions and restore the supported wording before saving the intended version.
A factual correction introduces a naming errorRecheck the product and variant against approved terminology.
An unresolved claim is central to the answerHold the affected output until the necessary evidence is available.
The draft is corrected but the live page is notComplete the separate destination update through the supported route and inspect the live result.

Your completion checklist

  • I reviewed the intended version against its audience, purpose and destination.
  • Important claims are connected to footage, applicable approved facts or clearly framed interpretation.
  • Product, variant, market and date context are correct.
  • Unsupported wording is removed, corrected or held for resolution.
  • The intended revision is saved and identifiable.
  • The headline, summary, FAQs and adaptations preserve the checked meaning.
  • Review, approval and publication actions are recorded separately.

Put the reviewed draft to work

Use What makes content from video useful enough to publish? for the final editorial check, then follow your normal approval and destination workflow. Return to AdCyte to apply the same process to the next output. Repeated corrections may also reveal a useful improvement to your brand guidelines or brief.

Where to go next

Continue reading

AdCyte newsletter

More from the work you already made.

Fresh perspectives on video advertising, useful content and AI discovery. Straight to your inbox.